Showing posts with label Film. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Film. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 27, 2016

Why Are Alternate History Adaptations So Poorly Made?

Guest post by Josh Weiss.

I recently re-read Robert Harris’s classic 1992 alternate history novel Fatherland in which a homicide detective in the Reich Kripo (Kriminalpolizei) attempts to solve the murder of a Party big-shot in a somewhat dystopian version of 1964 in which Germany won WWII. It’s a tour-de-force of a book that works on several levels as noir murder mystery, science fiction story and history lesson about Hitler’s “Final Solution” for the Jews and other European groups considered sub-human by the fascist ideology of National Socialism. Two words: Wannsee Conference.

Sounds like it would make a great movie, right? Of course and as it so happens, an adaptation of Fatherland was made by HBO only two years after the book’s publication, starring Rutger Hauer (Blade Runner) in the main role. However, the only problem is that the made-for-TV is so abysmal that it’s hard to watch … like extremely hard to watch, especially if you had just finished the book right before watching it like I had.

For one thing, not a shred of what makes the book great is contained within the almost two-hour movie that is just plain bad, even for a ‘90s feature. The plot is stripped of its integrity. Neither the dread nor the paranoia of a police state monitoring one’s every move. Not to mention the gaping absence of the ethical twist of the book’s big reveal for the characters. Horrible acting, the miscasting of every single major character and the trashy quality of the movie itself all work together to tarnish the good name of Robert Harris. Not even the presence of a younger Peter Vaughan (Maester Aemon on Game of Thrones) or seeing a Hitler impersonator with a greying moustache can save this sad excuse for a film.

Stick with the book and avoid it all costs. Now, you may be saying, “Well, it could just be an isolated incident in the world of alternate history adaptations.” Let me counter that with another AH scenario that would make another great movie.

One of the most notorious Nazi doctors of the Second World War—Josef Mengele—The Angel of Death himself--succeeds in making clones of Adolf Hitler with funds from a post-war SS network in the hopes of having the Fuhrer rise to power once more. A chilling sci-fi tale of intrigue and espionage, no?

Wish I’d thought of it, but that’s actually the plot of Ira Levin’s 1976 novel The Boys From Brazil. And again, it got a movie adaptation only two years after its publication. Like, Michael Crichton, Levin makes the science so believable, that you’ll be forced to concede that making clones of Hitler is downright easy. And so, the book involves a Simon Wiesenthal-esque Nazi hunter named Yaakov Lieberman trying to put a stop to the dastardly plot that never was. In reality, Mengele was never caught and lived out his years comfortably in South America with the occasional bother from Mossad agents attempting to bring him to justice.

So who was tapped to helm the Hollywood version of the book? None other than Franklin J. Schaffner, director of the sci-fi classic Planet of the Apes. So far so good. And who will act in it? Why two of the great thespians of the 20th century, Gregory Peck and Laurence Olivier. Shut the front door! There’s no way this movie can fail!

Oh, but it did and still does to this day. Again, the sound plot and names of characters are bastardized for no discernible reason. Although great actors, neither Peck nor Olivier were right for right for the roles in which they were cast:  Mengele and Lieberman respectively. Gone is the intrigue and race against the clock, the true evil of the plan. The acting is hammy and the direction is non-existent and the entire thing is as forgettable as a transitory case of amnesia.

So why has the butchery of great works of alternate history literature occurred in their translations to the screen? Personally, I blame it on the time periods between publication and production. In both instances, only two years passed between the book coming out and the release of a feature-length film adaptation. It’s sloppy is what it is. You can’t rush greatness and in these cases, stories that should have matured over time and become classics in their own right were plundered for cinematic gain.

Look at Amazon’s take of Philip K. Dick’s The Man in the High Castle. The book came out in 1962 and 54 years passed before anyone decided to try and make it work as a television show. And with today’s superior effects and budgets, that kind of world building is not only more believable, but more enthralling.

Just like history cannot be alternated until it’s already happened, so too, a book, especially one about AH, cannot be adapted until it has come into its own.

TL;DR: Stick to reading an alternate history book and avoid the movie at all costs.

* * *

Josh Weiss is a senior at Drexel University in Philadelphia, studying Communications with a concentration in Public Relations. As a die-hard lover of pop culture, he loves reading and writing about movies, superheroes, Lovecraftian horrors, hard boiled noir mysteries and, of course, alternate histories. As a lover of music, he collects vinyl and listen to the music of a bygone era like swing and disco. He's also thinking of picking up the ukulele. 

Monday, June 1, 2015

Weekly Update #193

Editor's Note

I was staring down a ton of tedious linking, mostly because of BBC's adaptation Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell, and I thought "screw this". I didn't set out to be a writer just to spend my day creating long list of links that can take hours to complete.

So say goodbye to the Links to the Multiverse section because this will be the last time you see it. I remember holding a poll a while back and people voted in favor of it, but I need to make an executive decision regarding the future of The Update. Does that mean I won't be sharing all the alternate history posts from the week? No, of course not. Instead of linking it to the Weekly Update post, however, I am going to be sharing them as I find them directly on Facebook and Twitter. So if you don't follow me on those sites, now is the time to do it.

So what does this mean for the Weekly Updates? How will I decide to what to write about if I am not collecting and categorizing articles and posts in my usual manner? Well that is the beauty of my new plan. YOU will decide what the subject(s) of the Weekly Update will be on Monday. After the week is over I will look through the posts on social media that got the most likes, comments, shares, replies, favorites, retweets, etc. and summarize them here on the blog and give my opinion (because everyone obviously loves to hear that). I may even apply the same formula to other long-running segments, like Map Mondays and Videos for Alternate Historians.

Does that all make sense? If not, don't worry, I will iron out the kinks as I get used to the new procedure. Hopefully this will make Weekly Updates easier to write and more fun for you all to read.

And now the news...

LXG Strikes Back
LXG sucked. It was the worst adaptation of an Alan Moore comic and it caused Sean Connery to quit acting. Nevertheless, it still made a lot of money, so that is probably why Fox decided to go ahead and reboot the franchise. According to Variety, John Davis (The Blacklist) will produce, Jayson Rothwell will write the script and Ira Napoliello and Matt Reilly are overseeing (whatever that means) the remake/reboot.

I sort of agree with Katharine Trendacosta of io9 reaction to this news. Since the original film was so bad, there really is no where to go but up for this reboot. Considering as well the high quality films and TV we have seen in the last couple years, audiences are demanding better content from the big studios. Whether they will actually create something that is watchable remains to be seen, but I am cautiously optimistic.

Links to the Multiverse

Books & Short Fiction

5 Great Steampunk Writings that Aren't Actually Steampunk at Pornokitsch.
6 Absolutely Magical Alternate Histories at B&N.
How Mowery (The Parallel Lives of Elizabeth Ann) Found Herself in Fantasy Land at SF Signal.
Review: At the Ruin of the World by John Henry Clay at Falcata Times.
Review: SS-GB by Len Deighton at Past Offences.
Why The Most Powerful Time Travel Stories Aren’t About Changing The Past at io9.

Counterfactuals, History & News

If Africa, Asia, and Europe Declared War on the U.S., Who Would Win? at Slate.
Forays into “What If” History: An After Action Report at American Historical Association.
This OS Almost Made Apple an Entirely Different Company at Wired.
Scotland Yard Feared Trekkies And Sci-Fi Fans In The Late 90s at ScienceFiction.com.
U.S. Army's New Battle Blimp Takes Flight at Popular Mechanics.
A White House without dogs? An alternate history of presidents minus the pups at Yahoo.
Why We'd Be Better Off if Napoleon Never Lost at Waterloo at Smithsonian.

Films & Television

Captain America 2 Animatics Reveal An Alternate Fate For Arnim Zola at io9.
George Miller’s Justice League Would Have Changed Superhero Movies Drastically at Tor.
Review: Outcast at Medievalists.Net.

Games

Once Upon A Timeline is a free game about time travel at PC Gamer

Graphic Novels & Comics

The Line it is Drawn #242 – Golden Age Versions of Modern Superheroes! at CBR.

* * *

Matt Mitrovich is the founder and editor of Alternate History Weekly Update and a blogger on Amazing Stories. Check out his short fiction. When not writing he works as an attorney, enjoys life with his beautiful wife Alana and prepares for the inevitable zombie apocalypse. You can follow him on Facebook or Twitter.

Thursday, January 8, 2015

Preview: The Atticus Institute

Got a film coming my way for review. It is called The Atticus Institute, a period horror piece that caught my eye. Here is the synopsis:

Dr. Henry West founded The Atticus Institute in the early 1970s to test individuals expressing supernatural abilities – E.S.P., clairvoyance, psychokinesis, etc. Despite witnessing several noteworthy cases, nothing could have prepared Dr. West and his colleagues for Judith Winstead. She outperformed every subject they had ever studied – soon gaining the attention of the U.S. Department of Defense, who subsequently took control of the research facility. The more experiments they conducted on Judith, the clearer it became that her abilities were the manifestation of evil forces within her, prompting the government to take measures to weaponize this force. But they soon discovered there are powers that exist in this world that simply cannot be controlled. Now the details of the inexplicable events that occurred within The Atticus Institute are being made public after remaining classified for nearly forty years.

It is written and directed by Chris Sparling and stars Rya Kihlstedt, William Mapother, Harry Groener, Rob Kerkovich, John Rubinstein, and Sharon Maughan. It is available on January 20, 2015 for those interested. Expect my review either here or on Amazing Stories.

* * *

Matt Mitrovich is the founder and editor of Alternate History Weekly Update and a blogger on Amazing Stories. Check out his short fiction. When not writing he works as an attorney, enjoys life with his beautiful wife Alana and prepares for the inevitable zombie apocalypse. You can follow him on Facebook or Twitter.

Wednesday, December 17, 2014

Review: War of the Worlds: Goliath

Guest post by Sean Korsgaard.
It’s been a while hasn't it? I apologize for the prolonged absence from the site folks, and hopefully, this will be the first of many more posts to come, but for today, I can think of nothing better to kick off my return than finally looking back at a movie I first talked about on this site back in 2012, War of the Worlds: Goliath.

First making waves back in 2012 in the Alternate History community, the movie was envisioned as a sequel to the events of HG Wells famous novel, where an Earth ravaged by the first Martian invasion digs in and fights back against the long awaited second attempt from the red planet to conquer our blue one. It’s easy to see why it made waves given some of the cult names behind the movie, to say nothing of the fact it surfaced around the same time as the release of another oddball independent AH-infused sci-fi extravaganza, Iron Sky.

Plus, it has President Roosevelt killing Martians with a laser cannon – that alone would be worth seeing.

That said, getting news on the development, or even the release date has always been somewhat tricky following the initial splash. Though it premiered in 2012, and was given a VERY limited release in the United States earlier this year, I haven’t yet heard much about the movie itself, much less even had the chance to see it myself. That is, until I chanced upon the movie on Netflix, and finally sat down to see if it could live up to the promise War of the Worlds: Goliath once showed.

In 1899, invaders from Mars attacked the Earth, easily beating back any and all resistance from the planet’s human inhabitants, the invasion failing only because of a lucky strike from earthly germs ravaging the Martians. Fifteen years later, they’re attempting to invade once more, but they will find a humanity far better armed and prepared this time. On the front lines is an international coalition dubbed A.R.E.S., created to both form a global defense force and reverse engineer Martian technology, they are now humanity’s best hope for once more driving the aliens from our home world – if they can put aside nationalism and fighting with each other long enough to fight for humanity that is.

I won’t even try to say otherwise, but if being a sequel to War of the Worlds wasn't your first clue, War of the Worlds: Goliath is a very silly movie, in all of the best of ways. Story wise, the movie is an above average Humanity-comes-together-to-kick-alien-arse movie ala Pacific Rim or Independence Day, and a few original touches aside, chooses to instead play on nearly every genre trope in the books, and I fully expect the degree of how much you enjoy this movie to be if you think that’s a good thing or a bad thing.

A good example would be our main protagonists, a typical five-man band where the closest thing to character development is an Irish member questioning whether an independent Ireland or humanity as a whole deserves the greater part of his loyalty. By the end of the movie, you might not even remember their names, yet the movie goes at a brisk enough pace that it never bothers you. Of course, part of that may be the movie has a few historical cameos whose appearances typically mark a high moment of the film, usually because they show up long enough to deliver one of the movie’s crowning moments of awesome. In case you’re curious, yes, mimetic badass President Roosevelt is everything you’d want and more.

From an animation and production standpoint, War of the Worlds: Goliath is a treasure trove, and very clearly a labor of love for the creators. Aside from a few moments where the animation looks jolty, something that should be expected given it’s a low budget independent animated film, from an animation standpoint War of the Worlds: Goliath is amazing, with the style best described as anime-inspired dieselpunk, as if Sunrise did a series based on Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow. The designs of the cities and military gear are always intimately detailed, and using CGI to animate the Martian tripods makes for an interesting stylistic contrast that highlights their alien nature.

War of the Worlds: Goliath may not be anything too out of this world, but it’s a fun little slice of cheesy goodness that more than overcomes any lack of ambition or originality. I’d compare the feel of the movie to one of the better cartoons from the 80s, like GI Joe or The Centurions, and for anyone who appreciates their charms, War of the Worlds: Goliath is worth watching.

A good litmus test to consider with War of the Worlds: Goliath is to ask if you’re the kind of person who wants an original story, developed characters, and cutting edge effects, or if you’re the kind of person who gets a big goofy grin on your face at the idea of the Red Baron dogfighting Martian spacecraft attacking a zeppelin while humming the Ride of the Valkyries. If you’re the former, you may lament that with a more developed script and story this could have been truly fantastic. If you’re the latter, strap yourself in for a top-notch B-movie and try to contain yourself when Teddy Roosevelt singlehandedly takes on a Martian air squadron.

While it may not be everyone’s cup of tea, I enjoyed War of the Worlds: Goliath myself [Editor's Note: as did I.], and fully expect it to become a cult classic within certain circles in good order. That said, even if it doesn't sound like your type of movie, given it’s just barely over an hour long and free to stream on Netflix, I recommend you give it a chance sometime.

* * *

Soldier, scholar, writer and web-voyeur, Sean CW Korsgaard has been active in the alternate history community since 2006. In addition to his contributions at the Alternate History Weekly Update, he writes for several websites, including his own, which can be found here.

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Review: War of the Worlds: Goliath

 
This week at Amazing Stories, I review the animated alternate history film War of the Worlds: Goliath. This film has been on my radar for quite some time and I was happy to finally have a chance to sit and watch it. Before you check out my review, you can also read a preview of the film from Sean Korsgaard and also see my interview with Goliath's director, Joe Pearson.

* * *

Matt Mitrovich is the founder and editor of Alternate History Weekly Update and a blogger on Amazing Stories. Check out his short fiction. When not writing he works as an attorney, enjoys life with his beautiful wife Alana and prepares for the inevitable zombie apocalypse. You can follow him on Facebook or Twitter.

Monday, March 17, 2014

Weekly Update #139

Editor's Note

I wanted to post my next entry in my World War I series last week, but with so much information coming in from NPR and Evans' article on counterfactuals I decided to postpone it so I can absorb all this new information. Don't worry, I still got plenty of great content on the way including some fun interviews and coverage on some World War I themed games.

As a reminder, you can support The Update's mission on providing the best news and reviews on alternate history by buying stuff through Amazon. Just click on the banner on the top right corner of the blog before you do so. You get to buy what you were going to buy anyway and we get to wet our beak a little in the process.

And now the news...

The Reviews Are In For 300: Rise of an Empire

Last week, 300: Rise of an Empire, sequel to the Frank Miller adaptation 300, was released. This  fictionalized retelling of the Battle of Salamis has done well at the box office, ensuring more sword and sandal films in the future. Whether that is a good or a bad thing, I leave up to the personal opinion of the reader. My personal opinion, strongly influenced from my viewing of The Immortals, is that it would be a a bad thing.

I will be honest: I don't have any intention of seeing this movie. Although I enjoyed 300 when I first saw it, the movie has not aged well for me. Luckily, several reviewers I respect have seen it for me and have shared their opinion of the flick on the Internet. Lets see what they had to say...

Let's start with the good:
  • Matthew Stienberg: All in all though the film is really satisfying and I couldn't have enjoyed it more. I'd heartily recommend it to anyone who wants to see a damn good action film.
  • The Man from Singapore: Go see it- I liked it but it could have been so much better.
And now the bad:
  • Matthew Quinn: Great concept, but it didn't live up to its full potential. It's a good movie to see--at the dollar theater. (Check out his supplemental post on the film and the Athen state.)
  • Sean Korsgaard: [I]t lacks the heart, the guts or the glory of the real deal, and ultimately betrays everything that made the previous film stand out.
So my hand picked reviewers are split on the film. What do you think?

Map Gallery

Now we will look at my three favorite maps of last week. First we have a beautiful map of sketchdoodle of the Brooke Kingdom of Sarawak & Sabah:
Not only is this a well drawn map, I like that it focuses on a part of the world often forgotten by alternate historians (except when the Japanese occupy it).

Next we have a world map from long time contributor Sean Korsgaard focusing on his Communist Confederacy timeline:
Great to see you producing more content for this world, Sean.

And we finish our trio of alternate history maps with a curious scenario featuring this 20th century Poland-wank by Zauis:
What I like about this wank is that it is quite believable. In this universe the Nazis do better against the Soviets, but still lose the war. The Soviets are confined to their 1939 border and a capitalist Poland is left in better shape to build a Eastern European coalition against the Soviets and any attempts by Germany (which I assume is not split in this timeline) to reclaim their old borders as well.

Submit your maps to ahwupdate at gmail dot com for a chance to be featured on next Monday's Weekly Update.

Video Gallery

And now the video portion of our weekly newsletter. First up, the book trailer for William Shakespeare's Star Wars: The Empire Striketh Back! by Ian Doescher:
If the trailer convinced you to pick up a copy, don't forget to click the link above to get it from Amazon. Next up, Cracked wants to inform you about the six myths you probably believe about the American Revolution:
Admittedly they over-simplified some of the reasons for the Revolution and completely ignored the fact that the French and Indian War was just another name for the Seven Years' War. If you want my take on the American Revolution, check out 6 Common Mistakes Every American Revolution Alternate History Makes.

Finally we end this week's video gallery with another video from friend of The Update Cody Franklin. He has the sequel to his what if the Soviets won the Cold War video:

Calendar

March 26: Jeff Greenfield will speak about his book If Kennedy Lived: The First and Second Terms of President John F. Kennedy: An Alternate History at the Clay Center in Charleston during the West Virginia University David C. Hardesty, Jr. Festival of Ideas.

April 1: Registration rates for Detcon1, the 2014 North American Science Fiction Convention, will go up.

Links to the Multiverse

Books and Short Fiction


“B-36”by Douglas W. Texter – Free Story Extract at Alt Hist.
Choosing A Favorite Historical Period by Miles Cameron at Bookworm Blues.
Egypt rules half the world in alternate history ‘three princes’ at Pop Mythology.
Excerpt: THE IRON JACKAL by Chris Wooding at SF Signal.
The Golem and the Jinni is a powerful masterpiece of historical fantasy by Andrew Liptak at io9.
Reaching back into the past to write the alternative present by Alison Morton at Alive on the Shelves.
Review: Then Will the Great Ocean Wash Deep Above by Ian Sales at UpComing4.Me.
Silk Road Fantasy and Breaking the Great Wall of Europe by Paul Weimer at SF Signal.
Table of Contents: THE CUTTING ROOM: DARK REFLECTIONS OF THE SILVER SCREEN Edited by Ellen Datlow at SF Signal.
This map describes the world of George Orwell's 1984—or does it? by Lauren Davis at io9.

Comics

Comic Review: Legenderry — A Steampunk Adventure at Amazing Stories.
The 5 Most Pointless “What If” Comics of All Time by Diana at Geek Pron.

Counterfactual/Traditional History

7 Utopias that Changed the Future by Annalee Newitz at io9.
10 Hardcore Female Military Leaders from History by Dan Wohl at The Mary Sue.
Best of Beyond Apollo I by David SF Portree at Wired.
British Jews in the first world war: spirit of the Maccabees by Adam Foulds at The Guardian.
Crowdsourcing Counterfactuals: NPR Asks: What If World War I Had Never Happened? by Gavriel D. Rosenfeld at The Counterfactual History Review.
The Latest Hitler Counterfactual: What If Hindenburg’s Last Will and Testament Had Come to Light? by Gavriel D. Rosenfeld at The Counterfactual History Review.
Really? Richard Evans Thinks Counterfactual History Is a "Waste of Time?" by Gavriel D. Rosenfeld at The Counterfactual History Review.

Films

Chrononaut script teaser by Zach Lipovsky at Vimeo.
Max Brooks' Harlem Hellfighters Graphic Novel Will Go To War For Sony by Nick Venable at Cinema Blend.

Interview

Mary Robinette Kowal at The Sword and Laser.
Jason Sharp at Three Cents Worth.
Dusty Wallace at Three Cents Worth.

Television

Elementary: Season 2, Episode 18. The Hound of the Cancer Cells at Thinking about books.
Syfy Greenlights 6-Hour Mini-Series ‘Ascension’ by Stuart Conover.
Revolution 2.16: The Manchurian Post-Blackout Patriot at Paul Levinson's Infinite Regress.

* * *

Matt Mitrovich is the founder and editor of Alternate History Weekly Update and a blogger on Amazing Stories. Check out his short fiction. When not writing he works as an attorney, enjoys life with his beautiful wife Alana and prepares for the inevitable zombie apocalypse. You can follow him on Facebook or Twitter.

Friday, February 28, 2014

The Dark Side of Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure

My brain works in weird ways. Just the other day I was thinking about Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure and realized there is something very bizarre about this film: all of the historical figures our titular characters picked up met nasty ends.

Check it out:
  • Napoleon: Died of stomach cancer (or possibly poisoned by arsenic) while exiled on St. Helena. (Age: 52)
  • Billy the Kid: Gunned down by the law. (Age: 21)
  • Socrates: Condemned to death and forced to poison himself. (Age: 71)
  • Freud: Euthanized with morphine after suffering from cancer of the jaw. (Age: 83, our oldest)
  • Genghis Khan: Unclear on how exactly he died, but either he was killed in battle, died from illness, fell from his horse or died from wounds sustained in hunting or battle. (Age 65)
  • Joan of Arc: Burned at the stake for heresy. (Age: 19, our youngest)
  • Abraham Lincoln: Assassinated by a Confederate sympathizer. (Age: 56)
  • Beethoven: Again unclear but depending on the source it was either alcoholic cirrhosis, syphilis, infectious hepatitis, lead poisoning, sarcoidosis, Whipple's disease or was accidentally poisoned by his doctors. (Age: 57)
Isn't it a little odd that the filmmakers picked such a cast of historical characters? Not a single one who died quietly in the night of old age after a long, successful life. With the exception of Socrates and Freud, most even died young by modern standards. The craziest thing is that even after everything they experienced while travelling through time they still went back.

Sure you could argue Bill and Ted were too ignorant of history to warn any of them, or that because no one else in the present really believed they were the real person they saw no reason to warn them either, but why not warn each other? Couldn't Abe have tapped Nappie on the shoulder and tell him why it is a bad idea to invade Russia during the winter? And why couldn't Freud jump in and talk about how Lincoln doesn't do well in theaters (disproved in 2012). Furthermore, wouldn't some of the characters have seen something of how their lives were going to turn out as Bill and Ted visited periods of time to pick up/drop off everyone?

They don't, however, learn anything at all about their personal futures. Time travel doesn't work that way! They would at the very least have accidentally stumbled on some aspect of their future. I mean...okay enough...its a comedy. Just let it go and stop ranting, Mitro.

Sorry for the nerd rant. Have a happy Friday, everybody!

* * *

Matt Mitrovich is the founder and editor of Alternate History Weekly Update and a blogger on Amazing Stories. His new short story "Road Trip" can be found in Forbidden Future: A Time Travel Anthology. When not writing he works as an attorney, enjoys life with his beautiful wife Alana and prepares for the inevitable zombie apocalypse. You can follow him on Facebook or Twitter.

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

The Andrew Wyly Film Company Acquires Rights to How Few Remain by Harry Turtledove

Here is some great news for alternate historians: the Andrew Wyly Film Company recently acquired the film rights to four books authored by Harry Turtledove: How Few Remain, The Great War: American Front, The Great War: Walk in Hell and The Great War: Breakthroughs. No word yet about the rest of the series or whether the infamous Jake Featherston will make an appearance.

For those who don't know, the series takes place in a very different America starting in 1881 with How Few Remain and ending in 1944 with In at the Death. The events occur in an alternate history where the Confederate States of America didn't lose the American Civil War. The point of divergence happens on September 10, 1862 during the American Civil War when General Robert E. Lee's Special Orders 191, which detailed Lee's plans, are not found by Union soldiers, leading to Confederate victory at the Battle of Antietam (or Sharpsburg in this timeline). Lee goes on to capture Philadelphia, earning the Confederate States of American diplomatic recognition from both Britain and France, thus winning the war (known as the War of Secession, see how much changes because of one forgetful errand boy).

Most of our readers know who Harry "The Master of Alternate History" Turtledove is, but for casual alternate historians should know that Turtledove is an award-winning author credited with bringing alternate history into the mainstream and known for a writing style that has a strong military theme. This blogger personally credits Turtledove for getting him interested in alternate history, an origin story I believe I share with several of you.

Andrew Wyly, the man behind the acquisition, says he is passionate about Turtledove's works due to his interest and background in history. "I'm looking forward to utilizing my skills as both a filmmaker and historian to bring audiences an entertaining twist on American History while maintaining the integrity of the novels," Wyly stated. Andrew, who has a BA in history from Denison University, founded the Andrew Wyly Film Company in 2007. Blood Shot, his first feature film, was completed last year along with his first book, Texas Got It Right! with his father, Sam Wyly.

Wyly is currently meeting with several studios and networks to find the right partner to develop and produce a 10 episode mini-series starting with How Few Remain. You can learn more information at HowFewRemain.com, but this alternate historian is already geeking out about the possibilities. We here at The Update wish Andrew the best of luck.

* * *

Matt Mitrovich is the founder and editor of Alternate History Weekly Update and a blogger on Amazing Stories. His new story "The Enchanted Bean" can be found in Once Upon a Clockwork Tale from Echelon Press. When not writing he works as an attorney, enjoys life with his beautiful wife Alana and prepares for the inevitable zombie apocalypse. You can follow him on Facebook or Twitter.

Thursday, June 20, 2013

Chronicles of the Socialist Republic by Dimas Aditya Hanandito

Entry for the DBWI Writing Contest.

#1
EXT. A COASTAL TOWN – DAY
*Traditional Asian flute playing on the background.

FADE IN.

A middle-aged MAN in civilian clothing is standing on the edge of a coast; his eyes focused on the empty, blue ocean. The sun is shining brightly, as if it would never set. Coastal wind blows his headband aslant. One can hear the sound of waves splashing into rocks and the lively squawks of seagulls. THE CAMERA ZOOMS IN to his weary but resolute face, seemingly making him older than his actual age.

MAN
[VOICEOVER] August, 1945. It is the fourth year of the Pacific War. The Committee has declared independence shortly following the fall of Hawaii. The American counterattack was swift and effective in retaking their most important Pacific base after letting the Japanese occupy it for three and a half years; yet, I am worried that we might have underestimated the Japanese capability to reaffirm their stand in the Pacific. With the Americans closing in to Okinawa, the Committee is very confident with the success of the movement. But they seem to deliberately neglect the fact that the Japanese are approaching the outskirts of Chongqing, which means they will be able to divert some of their forces to fight us before delivering another strike to the Americans. I warned the Committee that this revolution… Their revolution was one that is unprepared and unripe.

He reaches his breast pocket, taking out a folded letter. THE CAMERA ZOOMS IN to view the black ink handwriting as he unfolds it, stares it with looks of rue, and begins to read.

MAN’S BROTHER
[VOICEOVER] Dear brother, how are you? How are the people in the south? I hope everybody is fine. Our initial attacks were largely successful and the Northern Revolutionary Corps had managed to push the remnants of the Imperial Army to as far as Hyesan. I got sixteen on target last week, all heads; how about that? Now we are fortifying along the river, where we will face the Kwantung Army once and for all. After all of this ends, we will become fully independent again. Tae-chol will be coming to your place in a few days. Please take care of him while I am away. He is a diligent boy, he would be more than glad to help you with your business. Yours, Jae.

The man folds the letter, returns it to his pocket, and begins to shudder. His face, previously jaded but determined, gradually turns into an expression of rue and sorrow. THE CAMERA SHOOTS STEADILY to highlight the man’s anguishing visage.

MAN
[VOICEOVER] These people haven’t the slightest idea.

CUT TO BLACK.

No. Think again. He is right.

Who believed we were going to win that quickly anyway? If the Empire still exists, untouched, unblemished by any foreign power… Then our existence itself is in danger. There is no telling what they will do in the next two or three years. We would have no allies at that time. Something… 

Something profound has to happen if our survival is to be guaranteed.

The Americans. They must achieve greater victory. And the Chinese. They must resist longer.

(The sound of crumpling paper and scribbling)

#1B
INT. A BAR IN DOWNTOWN HEIJO – EVENING
*Sound of a band playing joyful folk music.

CUT IN.

THE CAMERA SHOOTS OVERHEAD on a bar. It is filled with cheering crowds; many in groups, some with their couples. Most of the men are dressed in standard-issue civilian uniform, while the women wear traditional or working uniform dresses. They dance, drink, laugh, and embrace each other in joy. One can see they keep the bartender busy behind his counter, taking out more and more bottles. Among the crowd, TAE-CHOL, a young man in his early twenties, raises his glass of soju and swallows it in one gulp. He is about 5’5” tall, wearing olive shirt and pants. His girlfriend, a pretty commoner of his age HYEON-AE, embraces him from behind. She sports a 5’2” height and wears a dark green civilian dress.

HYEON-AE
(cheerfully) Tae-chol! So what are we going to do after this?

TAE-CHOL
(smiling) We go south. My uncle lives in Keijo; he allows me to work at his factory, where he produces cement. There’s got to be good demand for it after the war. (pauses) I’m sure the Americans would be heading here as soon as they make the Empire surrender, which means we’ll have the opportunity to rebuild this nation with their help.

HYEON-AE
(happy tears) I’m glad it’s finally over. Nobody is waiting for me at home. I will go wherever you will.

TAE-CHOL
Don’t worry my love; we’ve been through the hardest moment together, we’ll make this to the end together.

THE CAMERA ZOOMS OUT from the couple as their faces get close to kiss, REVOLVES around the bar, and ZOOMS IN to a Revolutionary Force pamphlet lying beside bottles and cups on the table. The date is August 4, 1945. It reads:

KYUSHU FELL! IMPERIAL NAVY SUFFERS SETBACKS IN VARIOUS FRONTS! AMERICANS HEAD STRAIGHT TO THE HOME ISLANDS!

Suddenly, the bar door is knocked open. A YOUNG MAN in traditional outfit, his hands holding his Arisaka rifle, enters hastily and shouts.

YOUNG MAN
(gasping) They are here!

*The band stops playing music. Silence.

Rifle shots suddenly pierce the wooden walls of the bar. Several people are hit, including the Young Man. Tae-chol grabs Hyeon-ae’s arm and flings her behind the bar. He then takes cover behind a table. He brandishes his stolen Nambu pistol, cocks the firearm, and begins firing back. Several men are also taking out their sidearms while the women evacuate. The bartender draws his shotgun from the counter, successfully fires it on a charging Imperial soldier.

The gunfight continues wildly. Bullets pass through soju bottles and cups, leaving cheap broken ceramics and glasses all over the place. Some of the attackers begin using submachine guns, tearing the wooden entrance apart. More men inside the bar are shot. Tae-chol maneuvers behind fallen tables, and shoots a submachine gunner through the window. A rifle bullet then grazes his left shoulder. Hyeon-ae, witnessing the entire event from behind the counter, shouts to his lover.

HYEON-AE
Tae-chol!

A grenade is then thrown inside the bar. It explodes with loud bang.

CUT TO BLACK.

FADE IN.

A wounded Tae-chol awakes in midst of a rubble which is previously a bar counter. There is blood all over his face and hands. Bodies of revolutionaries and Imperial soldiers are all over the place. He observe many familiar faces, eyes wide open. But he just starts to tremble as he find out that beside him lays the soulless body of Hyeon-ae, cold and unmoving. Tae-chol shatters.

CUT TO BLACK.

I can’t believe it. This doesn’t sound right.

I have seen this divergence someplace! It was Shimamura... Or Okabayashi. The Empire surrenders and then our independence. A challenging premise: most of them had the divergence centered on Hawaii. If the Americans could go beyond Eastern Pacific, they might as well go as far as making the home islands within reach of their bombers. But hell, they couldn't even retake Hawaii back then. Weaklings. I thought the Americans outsized our industrial might ten to one. Perhaps the occupation of Pearl Harbor was indeed the major turning point.

And what about that fantasy-bomb they thought won the war? Although I have to say Okabayashi’s premise is interesting; with Einstein surviving his assassination attempt in Antwerp, he could renounce his citizenship and return to America anytime he wanted. Still, I doubt he could be of any help to the Americans more than Heisenberg was to the Germans.

Or better yet, more than Nishina was to the Empire.

Well, maybe I’m apathetic, but I’m a realist nevertheless. I can’t go on with this. Here’s my point: suppose the Americans managed to fantasy-bomb the home islands, the Kwantung Army would still be intact. Given the battle-hardened fervor of the armed forces, there is no way they are going to surrender that instant. The peninsula in particular would still be in their possession. Most importantly, any of our revolutionary efforts would be met with force. Heck, those revolutionaries might get slaughtered before the Americans are even finished with the bulk of the Imperial Army and get to the peninsula. Honekawa-san wants me to make something original, something appalling, something stronger and more convincing.

So, what’s worse than fighting a great power? Fighting two great powers at once, of course. From two different directions.

Alright. Let’s pull the divergence far, far beyond, beyond any of them has ever thought before. I’m going to take this to Europe.

(Another sound of paper crumpling and scribbling, this time steadier)

#1C
INT. COUNTRY HOUSE – EVENING
*Silence.

FADE IN.

One can see a calendar hanging aside an old family photo. Every date on the calendar has red circles, ending on August 31, 1945. Suddenly a ceramic teapot is thrown to the wall. It breaks IN SLOW MOTION with a loud crash, splattering the tea within it all over the wall and the surrounding floor. THE CAMERA PANS to shoot TEENAGER, who is about to exit the house, stops at the moment the teapot hits the wall. He turns to face his FATHER, a middle-aged man, who stands in anger. One can see the MOTHER and the YOUNGER BROTHER on the corner of the room, looking frightened.

FATHER
(furiously) No! I’m saying you won’t go! You stay and we wait for the Americans!

TEENAGER
What else, father? Are you going to wait for them to come and have all of us rounded as slaves? I am a proud soldier of the Empire, father. My loyalty lies with the Emperor. To the north I shall go, to fight with my brethren and halt the Soviet onslaught from defiling our lands. To die for the Emperor is the greatest honor for an imperial subject!

FATHER
You are not even born in their lands! How could you call yourself a subject of that goddamned Emperor? Didn't you remember how they slaughtered your cousin in Heijo? They murdered him in cold blood!

The Mother begins to sob in the corner. The Younger Brother, looking confused, hugs his mom in consolation.

TEENAGER
That treacherous fellow resisted! I knew he had ties with the Revolutionary Committee. He has been operating with the Heijo Underground all these months, communicating in secret with the Americans and the Soviets. He deserved to get what he got along with that disloyal woman of his!

The Father can no longer withstand the insolence. He steps forward and hits the Teenager on the face. The Teenager stumbles.

FATHER
You step outside this house (pauses, hesitates), you are no longer a member of this family.

The Teenager quickly returns on his feet, stares his father on the eye for a second, and then exits the house with a loud slamming on the door.

CUT TO BLACK.

Wait. If the Soviets made it through Moscow and had the Germans pummeled all the way to Berlin, it should be inevitable that they shifted their attention to the East. Given the situation in Europe, Moscow should have been the most decisive campaign of all. The Germans were bullseye when von Bock went all the way to Moscow. There should be something... (Sound of books being rummaged, pages being whirled) A-ha!
The Germans must be delayed from reaching Moscow. There is a good possibility that they went for Ukraine at that time, and I’m going to make exactly that... Perfect. Now if the Red Army managed to withhold and subsequently crush the Wehrmacht with sufficient defense in Moscow, they would be able to drive the Germans completely away from Russian land by, say, autumn of 1944.
Then they will turn east.
(Sudden realization)
What was I thinking? Why stop at helping the North create their own government or establishing a client state? If the Americans cannot even pass through Hawaii by 1945, the Soviets would find it a walk in the park to sweep the entire peninsula at one stroke. I think they could even reach the southern tip by September, no, August 1945.
I think I might be close to a possibility none of them ever been before.

(Sound of papers being crumpled and thrown away)

#1D
INT. PYONGYANG METRO SAMHUNG STATION – MORNING
*Sound of underground train passing. Railroad creaks.

CUT IN.

THE CAMERA SHOOTS on an arriving train. Hundreds of people, men and women and children, exit the carriage as its doors open. Among the commuters is NAM-SE, a 19-year old student of Korean State University. He has a clean, round face covered with curly black hair. Unlike most of his people, his eyes are moderately slanted and his nose firm. The 5’9” figure walks briskly towards the exit, wearing a brown coat over his checkered white shirt and black pants, his left hand carrying a leather bag.

EXT. STREETS IN FRONT OF SAMHUNG STATION – MORNING
*Sound of morning traffic and pedestrian busyness.

One can hear the approaching winter through the autumn winds as Nam-se takes the staircase to the surface. Falling leaves are being blown away. He goes across the road in front of the metro station and turns left, walking along the sidewalks. As he walks, THE CAMERA HIGHLIGHTS the skyline of the city.

NAM-SE
[VOICEOVER] Pyongyang. Sometimes I still can’t believe I made it here.

Nam-se passes a park with statues as he heads to a student apartment complex, where he enters one of the brown, brick edifices.

INT. GWANGGURYEO STUDENT APARTMENT – MORNING

Prior to boarding the stairs, Nam-se greets OLD MAN HO in the reception.

NAM-SE
Good morning Mr. Ho!

OLD MAN HO
Good morning! Nam-se, there were several boys looking for you just now. They left just a while ago and didn't leave any names. You made any appointment?

NAM-SE
Well, that’s strange. I don’t recall having any agenda with anybody today.

OLD MAN HO
(shrugs) Well, I hope there won’t be any problem then.

NAM-SE
No worries Mr. Ho. Thank you for keeping me informed.

He waves to Old Man Ho as he heads to his flat on the second floor. He lives in a 5-floor small student apartment with four flats each floor. He inserts the key to the third door from the stairs, which opens after two clicks.

INT. NAM-SE’S FLAT – MORNING

Nam-se puts his leather bag on a small table by the window, on which lays a photograph of his family; his father, mother, and older brother. THE CAMERA SHOOTS on the picture, taken fourteen years ago in front of his father’s cement factory. Suddenly HYO-RI, a shadowy figure, greets him from behind.

HYO-RI
You seem to have a nice, memorable childhood.

Nam-se turns his back on reflex to find a girl of his age standing in front of him. She wears dark green short-sleeved shirt on top of his blue skirt.

NAM-SE
(calmly) Memorable, yes; nice, not necessarily. Who are you? How did you get in?

HYO-RI
(giggles) You answered coolly. We always find some way. My name is Hyo-ri. I need you to listen to this important proposition I’m going to make.

NAM-SE
What is this all about?

HYO-RI
What are you?

NAM-SE
What kind of question is that? What do you suppose me to answer? A student?

HYO-RI
Well, so am I. Though I need a cooler answer than that (giggles). Let’s show each other our IDs.

NAM-SE
Why should I trust you?

HYO-RI
Oh come now, what’s so troubling about fellow students showing each other their IDs?

The two of them, both being students, flash their student IDs to each other. Nam-se’s ID reads:

KOREAN STATE UNIVERSITY
NAME                :  JI NAM-SE
ID NUMBER       :  119 21058 0024
NATIONALITY    :  SOVIET
DEPARTMENT   :  KIM SONG-JU SCHOOL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

HYO-RI
(continues) Let me ask you one question. Are you really a Soviet?

NAM-SE
(puzzled hesitation) What do you expect? I was born in the Korean SSR.

HYO-RI
So was I again. Gosh, we had a lot in common. Do you have any relatives in Korea?

NAM-SE
If by Korea you meant the republic in the south, my brother went there during the war to help defend the peninsula against the Americans. He never came back and I never heard from him since. What does he have to do with this?

HYO-RI
I see. Well, that’s why I think you will be interested with our proposition. I’m talking about reuniting you and your brother. And many other families separated after the war. I’m talking about sec…

Before Hyo-ri can finish her sentence, there are sounds of hasty footsteps on the corridor outside. There seems to be several people heading to his flat. Hyo-ri, aware of the sounds, becomes alerted.

HYO-RI
Bad luck. They are coming this way. Come, you have to follow me!

* * *

Crispy. This is fun! I can make this an espionage thriller. Young Nam-se wants his family to be one once again. Far within his heart he knows he is a Korean, not a Soviet! I think this is going to sell amidst the ongoing sentiment that we are Koreans, not Japanese!
“Oi Shuichi! Why are you talking to yourself?” a voice alerted the scriptwriter.
“Motaro! What the hell are you doing in my flat?”
“Calm down! I was here since afternoon, remember? Went out to buy some bento from nearby konbini. You told me you are going to write something big today. Figured out you might want to be undisturbed so I took home some food to eat. I hardly believe somebody like you can fill your stomach only by writing.”
“I can,” argued Shuichi. “Honekawa-san is going to pay big for this.”
Motaro rummaged through the scraps of paper Shuichi threw away, skimmed them one by one.
“What’s this? You scrapped all these altogether? Americans retake Hawaii, Korean independence; Americans strike to Kyushu, Korean independence; Soviets invade Manchuria, Korean independence; these are hell of a timeline. You’re politically Korean now? You going to make use of next week’s Co-prosperity Day demonstration to pitch your writing to Honekawa-san?”
“You know as well as I do I’m never really into politics. But I’m well into anything which can turn my writing into yen. You’re free to comment.”
“Speaking of which, you really think the Soviets can make it through Moscow? If I show this to Franz he’s going to laugh his ass off. You remember that Nazi drunkard? Wow! The Empire under attack from two directions? I can’t even imagine the Americans could retake Hawaii with the death of Nimitz. Hey, what about that one you’re currently writing?”

“Anything can happen, Motaro. In alternate worlds, even the unthinkable can happen.”

* * *

Dimas Aditya Hanandito is s junior ucroniador from the Far East currently in his final years of college who sometimes delves into the alternate past out of boredom of the present reality.